12670 County Road 250
Durango, CO 81301
Welcome to The Rusty Nail Ranch — a rare 70-acre riverfront legacy estate set along the storied banks of the Animas River. This is Colorado as it was meant to be experienced: private, water-rich, and framed by towering ponderosa pines with the river running strong through its heart. With over a quarter mile of direct river frontage, the land unfolds in layers — a mature pine forest anchoring the entrance and two lush irrigated pastures stretching across more than 10 acres. A fully appointed equestrian setup includes an arena, four-stall barn, tack room, wash bay, and supporting infrastructure designed for both serious horsemen and recreational riders alike. The 5,230 sq ft main residence is thoughtfully positioned to capture river views and the sound of moving water from its expansive wrap-around deck. Inside, a vaulted great room sets the tone, complemented by Venetian plaster walls, private study, dedicated office, and a remarkable primary suite featuring his and her bathrooms, and lower-level entertainment room with bar, office, and guest suite. Every space reflects craftsmanship, comfort, and connection to the land. A 1,500 sq ft guest residence sits above an oversized three-car garage, offering two bedrooms and two bathrooms — ideal for hosting extended family or long-term guests. The Caretaker’s Quarters seamlessly integrate ranch operations with comfortable living, featuring a two-bedroom, two-bath residence connected to the barn and additional garage space. In front of the main home, a fully stocked rainbow trout pond is continuously fed by fresh river water, creating a private fishing experience supported by exceptional water quality and minimal maintenance. Water is the lifeblood of any true Western ranch, and The Rusty Nail delivers. Senior rights include 1 CFS (448 GPM) in perpetuity from the river, supporting the trout pond and approximately 10 acres of irrigation, along with residential well rights of 15 GPM. Steeped in regional lore, the ranch sits just feet from historic Baker’s Bridge, famously featured in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. With Purgatory Resort just minutes away and access to vast surrounding public lands, this property offers year-round recreation without compromising privacy. The Rusty Nail Ranch is more than a home — it is a generational holding, a water-secured river estate, and a true piece of the American West.
- 7 Beds
- 9 Baths
- 9448 Square Feet
- Appliances: Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer, Microwave, Double Oven, Exhaust Fan
- Flooring: Hardwood,Tile
- Cooling: Central A/C
- Interior Inclusions: Part Furnished
- Zoning: Residential Single Family
- 70.670 Acres
- Garage: Attached Garage
- Roof: Wood Shingle
- Fencing: Full Property
- Horse Setup
- Exterior Inclusions: Deck, Gas Grill
- Elementary: Animas Valley K-5
- Middle: Miller 6-8
- High: Durango 9-12
Courtesy of Josiah Goodson 970-749-8598 josiah@josiahgoodson.com

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2026. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to "limited license" rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited.
FULL CREN Disclaimer
Real Estate listings held by companies other than Gunnison Real Estate & Rentals LLC contain that company's name.
Fair Housing Disclaimer
This data was last updated: 2026-04-02 12:16pm
View All Listings
$32,000,000
401 Larkspur Lane, Mountain Villagebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Strategically set on a premier ski-in/ski-out site with awe-inspiring views of surrounding peaks, this One Architects-designe…more details
$25,000,000
7 Moon Ridge Lane, Crested Buttebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Sunflower Ranch is a remarkable 124.6 acre property in Gunnison County. It is adjacent to the town of Crested Butte, and shar…more details
$22,400,000
10931 County Road 742, Almontbed
sq ft
acre
Taylor River Lodge is a sanctuary for those who seek nature without compromise. Tucked into the dramatic Taylor Canyon beneat…more details
$17,500,000
3456 County Road 124, Hesperusbed
bath
sq ft
acre
"LUXURY IN THE MOUNTAINS!" Describes this 175-acre estate that borders three sides of 1.85 million acres of the SanJuan Natio…more details
$16,950,000
2500 CR 505, Bayfieldbed
bath
sq ft
acre
Pine Ridge Ranch is an exceptional 1,375-acre legacy property offering breathtaking natural beauty, serene privacy, and the u…more details
$15,950,000
228 Benchmark Drive, Mountain Villagebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Featured in Architectural Digest for its exceptional design & interior spaces, this mountain Arts & Crafts-styled home, remod…more details
$14,900,000
50221 HWY 550 Highway, Durangobed
bath
sq ft
acre
Luxury Castle-Style Home in the Heart of the San Juan Mountains with Private pond on ample acreage Square Footage: • Indo…more details
$13,900,000
250 Benchmark Drive, Mountain Villagebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Gracefully set upon a gentle rise atop Benchmark Drive, this wonderfully re-envisioned residence offers unparalleled views ov…more details
$13,500,000
119 Palmyra Drive, Mountain Villagebed
bath
sq ft
acre
A rare blend of effortless ski access, refined mountain design, and expansive family living define this exceptional ski-in/sk…more details
$13,500,000
23 Gray Fox Lane, Mt. Crested Buttebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Perched at the top of the prestigious Prospect subdivision in Mt. Crested Butte, 23 Gray Fox Lane- known as The Tipple House-…more details
$11,900,000
167 Adams Ranch Road, Mountain Villagebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Exquisitely designed & finished mountain contemporary residence offering breathtaking views along this sought-after stretch o…more details
$10,995,000
28 Kokanee Lane, Mt. Crested Buttebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Perched above the East River Valley in the exclusive Prospect neighborhood of Mt. Crested Butte, 28 Kokanee Lane is a rare sk…more details
$10,950,000
1268 Brown Ranch Road, Placervillebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Set within the gated enclave of Brown Ranch on Iron Springs Mesa, ''Stoneflower'' is a masterfully crafted 75-acre mountain r…more details
$10,750,000
1701 & 1729 CR 250, Durangobed
bath
sq ft
acre
Rarely does an opportunity of this magnitude present itself. Riversong Ranch, two of the Animas Valley's most exceptional riv…more details
$9,980,000
721 E Columbia, Telluridebed
bath
sq ft
acre
New compelling price. Unmatched panoramic views of Bear Creek Canyon and the San Juan peaks define this iconic Telluride resi…more details
$9,750,000
1050/973 Posey Road, Placervillebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Gracefully positioned amidst a series of rolling meadows, framed by the towering beauty of the snow-capped Wilson Range, Silv…more details
$9,400,000
XXX CR TBD, Hesperusbed
bath
sq ft
acre
Three Canyons Ranch boasts magnificent 5,196 square foot Colorado-style home that seamlessly marries rustic charm with modern…more details
$8,950,000
1294 County Road 734, Crested Buttebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Perched high above the Slate River with sweeping views from Paradise Divide to Mt. Crested Butte and the valley floor, Blue H…more details
$8,550,000
18 Walking Deer Lane, Mt. Crested Buttebed
bath
sq ft
acre
Welcome to the epitome of Crested Butte luxury living! Nestled in the heart of Mt. Crested Butte and sitting directly on the…more details
$8,495,000
3601 Hidden Valley Drive, Pagosa Springsbed
bath
sq ft
acre
A Truly Irreplaceable Legacy Offering in Pagosa Springs — this private, multi-generational ranch compound in Hidden Valley…more details

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2026. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to "limited license" rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited.
FULL CREN Disclaimer
Real Estate listings held by companies other than Gunnison Real Estate & Rentals LLC contain that company's name.
Fair Housing Disclaimer
This data was last updated: 2026-04-02 12:16pm
